How to Train a Stubborn Dog: 8 Trainer-Backed Fixes That Actually Work
This post contains Amazon affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Pups Gourmet Kitchen earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Wondering how to train a stubborn dog? Most “stubborn” dogs are under-motivated or confused, not defiant — so find a reward they truly want, make the task easier, train in short sessions with fewer distractions, and reward every small step.
Key Takeaways
- “When a dog doesn’t listen to or follow commands, it’s not typically because he is hardheaded or untrainable,” says trainer Mikkel Becker (Vetstreet).
- “Dogs are individuals and have preferences for rewards,” notes AKC trainer Sassafras Patterdale, CPDT-KA — rank yours from kibble to freeze-dried meat (AKC).
- Match the reward to the difficulty: low-value food for easy skills at home, high-value food for distractions outdoors.
- Consistency matters — everyone in the house should use the same cues and rewards.
- 11% of dogs in a 502-owner survey had “disobedience” problems like not coming when called.
- Skip corrections: the AVSAB says aversive methods “can cause stress in dogs.”
You say “come.” Your dog looks at you, considers it, and goes back to sniffing a leaf. If you’re wondering how to train a stubborn dog, here’s the reassuring truth trainers repeat again and again: stubbornness is usually a motivation or communication problem, not a personality flaw. Change what the dog gets out of listening, and “stubborn” dogs often turn into star pupils.
Why is my dog so stubborn?
A dog who doesn’t respond is usually telling you one of four things: “I don’t understand,” “that’s not worth it,” “there’s something more interesting here,” or “I don’t feel well.” As trainer Mikkel Becker puts it on Vetstreet, “When a dog doesn’t listen to or follow commands, it’s not typically because he is hardheaded or untrainable.”
Breed plays a part, too. Scent hounds like beagles and basset hounds were bred to follow their noses for miles, and northern breeds like huskies were bred to make independent decisions. These dogs aren’t less smart — they just need better pay and more patience.
What are the best ways to train a stubborn dog?
These eight fixes cover the most common reasons a dog tunes you out. Work through them in order.
1. Rule out pain, hearing loss, and confusion
A dog who won’t sit may have sore hips; a dog who ignores you may not hear well. If refusal is new or sudden, see your vet first. Then ask yourself honestly: does your dog really know this cue in this place? Dogs don’t generalize well — a sit in the kitchen isn’t automatically a sit at the park.
2. Find what your dog will work for
“Dogs are individuals and have preferences for rewards,” says Sassafras Patterdale, CPDT-KA, writing for the AKC. Test four types of rewards — food, play, the chance to sniff and explore, and praise — then rank your dog’s favorites. For most “stubborn” dogs, food wins. Our high-protein dog treats and chicken and cheese treats are high-value favorites.
| Reward value | Examples | Use it for |
|---|---|---|
| Low | Kibble, plain biscuits | Easy, known skills in a quiet room |
| Medium | Standard training treats, crunchy biscuits | Practice in the yard or on quiet walks |
| High | Freeze-dried meat, string cheese, bits of chicken | New skills, recall, busy places, distractions |
| Jackpot | A handful of high-value treats or a favorite game of tug | A breakthrough moment, or a great recall |
3. Keep sessions short and fun
Several quick sessions a day beat one long one. Stop while your dog still wants more, and always end on a success. Becker recommends making training a habit by working short practice into daily routines — ask for a sit before meals, a down before the leash goes on, a stay at the door.
4. Lower the distractions
If your dog “knows” a cue at home but ignores it outside, the environment is winning. Go back to a quieter spot, then add distractions one at a time: the yard, the sidewalk, the park at a quiet hour, then the busy park.
5. Break it into smaller steps
If your dog won’t do the whole behavior, reward part of it. For a stubborn down, reward elbows bending before you expect a full down. For recall, reward a head turn before you ask for a full sprint back.
6. Say the cue once
Repeating “sit, sit, SIT” teaches your dog that the first two don’t count. Say it once, wait a few seconds, and help your dog succeed with a lure if needed.
7. Make everyone consistent
If one person says “down” for lie down and another uses it for “get off the couch,” your dog isn’t being stubborn — they’re confused. Agree on cues as a household.
8. Use “life rewards”
Many dogs want things more than treats: the door opening, the leash clicking on, the ball being thrown, the chance to sniff. Ask for a quick behavior first, then give access. It’s the easiest way to build motivation into everyday life.
Helpful gear for “stubborn” dogs
- Freeze-dried liver treats — a classic high-value reward that’s easy to break into tiny bits.
- A clip-on treat pouch so you can reward in the moment, every time.
- A training clicker to mark the exact second your dog gets it right.
- A 30-foot long line for safe recall practice outdoors.
What should you avoid with a stubborn dog?
- Punishment and force. Leash pops and yelling add stress and damage trust. The AVSAB’s 2021 position statement concludes that “reward-based dog training offers the most advantages and least harm to the learner’s welfare,” and adds that “studies show that aversive methods can cause stress in dogs.”
- Poisoning your cue. Don’t call your dog to end fun or for something unpleasant, like a bath. Our recall guide explains how to keep “come” positive.
- Bribing instead of rewarding. Showing the treat first and only then asking is a bribe. Keep treats hidden in a pouch, ask for the behavior, then reward.
- Overfeeding. Count training treats as part of your dog’s daily food, and use pea-sized pieces.
Which dog breeds are considered the most stubborn?
Breeds often labeled stubborn include beagles, basset hounds, bloodhounds, Siberian huskies, Shiba Inus, Akitas, Chow Chows, and many terriers. What they share is independence: they were bred to hunt, track, or work at a distance without constant direction. With the right rewards and plenty of patience, all of them can learn reliable manners. A good group class or a qualified reward-based trainer helps, and working on leave it and leash walking gives independent breeds useful structure.
Frequently asked questions
Are some dogs just untrainable?
Almost never. Dogs that seem untrainable are usually unmotivated, confused, distracted, or uncomfortable. Changing the reward, the environment, or the size of the step usually makes the difference.
What is the best treat for a stubborn dog?
Whatever your dog values most. For many dogs, that’s soft, smelly meat or cheese treats. The AKC recommends saving high-value rewards like freeze-dried meat or string cheese for difficult skills and distracting places.
How long should training sessions be for a stubborn dog?
Keep them short — a few minutes at a time, several times a day. End while your dog is still engaged and successful.
Should I punish my dog for ignoring commands?
No. Punishment adds stress and doesn’t teach your dog what to do. The AVSAB recommends reward-based training for all dogs.
Why does my dog listen at home but not outside?
Dogs don’t generalize well, and the outdoors is full of competing rewards. Practice in many locations, lower distractions at first, and use higher-value treats outside.
Is my dog stubborn or just smart?
Often both. Smart, independent dogs quickly learn when listening pays and when it doesn’t. Make the payoff consistent and worthwhile.
When should I hire a trainer for a stubborn dog?
If you’ve been consistent for a few weeks without progress, or if your dog shows fear or aggression, work with a qualified reward-based trainer. Mikkel Becker also suggests involving your veterinarian or a veterinary behaviorist when needed.
